DataPR
Let's Talk
Insights — Signal / 019

Why small businesses need press mentions, not just a Google Business Profile.

Only 35% of small businesses even have a complete Google Business Profile. Fixing that gets you to parity with a third of your competitors. Here's what actually gets you ahead of the rest.

Why small businesses need press mentions, not just a Google Business Profile

Only 35% of small businesses have a fully set-up Google Business Profile. That's a strange number to sit with, since the advice to claim and complete one has been repeated for a decade, everywhere small business marketing gets discussed.

What's actually happening with the other 65%?

Roughly 41% of small local businesses currently operate with incomplete profile information, and around 34% have never posted a single update — meaning the gap isn't awareness, it's follow-through, on a task that takes minutes and moves real numbers.

A complete profile drives 70% more location visits than an incomplete one, and Business Profile signals alone control about 32% of local pack ranking weight, with review signals contributing another 16% and citation consistency 7%. That's most of what determines whether a business shows up in the local 3-pack that now appears on 93% of local-intent searches.

Why this matters more than it sounds: customers are 2.7 times more likely to trust a business with a complete profile, 97% read reviews before visiting, and "near me" mobile searches have grown roughly 900% over two years — with 28% of those searches converting to a purchase within a week. This is the highest-leverage, lowest-effort marketing move available to almost any local business, and a third of the market still hasn't done it.

So isn't a complete profile enough on its own?

It closes the gap with competitors who also complete theirs, but it can't create a gap over them — once every business in a market has full hours, categories, and photos filled in, the profile stops being anything other than the baseline everyone shares.

Local SEO already delivers a cost-per-lead 61% lower than traditional outbound marketing for small businesses, which is a genuinely strong return — but it's a return everyone in the same category can also capture once they catch up on the basics. The differentiation has to come from somewhere else.

What does press coverage actually add that a profile can't?

A profile is self-reported — a business writing its own description, choosing its own photos, controlling its own message. A press mention is the opposite: proof that someone with no stake in the business decided it was worth writing about, which is exactly the kind of signal that carries weight with both customers and AI search in a way a self-managed profile never can.

That distinction shows up directly in how people search now, too — a growing share of "best [service] near me" queries get answered by an AI Overview or assistant synthesizing from whatever it can find about local businesses, and a profile written by the business itself gives that synthesis nothing independent to draw from.

What's a realistic first press story for a small business?

The most overlooked angle is a business's own operational data — years in business, number of customers served, a genuine local-market observation drawn from actual transaction history — turned into a specific local number a reporter can cite.

A bakery that's tracked ingredient costs for five years has real inflation data most local reporters would want for a cost-of-living story. A contractor who's done two hundred kitchen remodels has real numbers on what's actually changed in the category this year. That's the same principle behind turning a spreadsheet into a story journalists chase, scaled down to a business with no research department and no marketing budget beyond what's already sitting in its own records.

"A complete profile gets you to the same starting line as every competitor who also bothered to fill it out. A press mention is the only thing on this list nobody else can copy by the weekend."

The basics still matter — an incomplete profile is real money left on the table, and fixing it is worth doing regardless. But for a small business trying to actually stand out in a crowded local market, the ceiling on profile optimization is a lot lower than most owners assume, and the room above it is almost entirely uncontested.

Back to all Insights Next: ChatGPT and Perplexity are sending real traffic now
Ready when you are

Let's get you covered.